phone mail2 facebook twitter play
FILM REVIEW: Sully
Image Credit: Warner Brothers

FILM REVIEW: Sully

26 November 2016 Edd Elliott  | Entertainment

An age-old tale of man versus machine, Clint Eastwood’s Sully finds tension aplenty but struggles with its “true story” tag.

“Brace for impact!” Three words no flyer wants to hear. All those ignored pre-flight safety instructions have come back with a vengeance. We were all fiddling with our phones or reading about completely indispensible sports gilets in Sky Mall magazine – well done us. The announcement of impending disaster, one imagines, would be softened slightly by its delivery in the dulcet tones of Tom Hanks. But the thought of “Why is Tom Hanks flying the plane?” would very quickly be pushed aside by “I’m plummeting towards the earth at 600mph!”

Interestingly, Sully – Clint Eastwood’s re-dramatization of the “Miracle on the Hudson”, the emergency landing of US Airways Flight 1549 on New York’s Hudson River in January 2009 – is more concerned with the aftermath of this dance with destruction. Tom Hanks plays the titular Capt. Chelsey “Sully” Sullenburger, the man at the wheel for the death-defying plummet. The whole world thinks he is a hero. The NTSB (National Transportation Safety Board), however, are not so sure. Early simulations of the flight indicate the passenger jet could have made it back to a runway, and there is even suggestion that one of the engines may still have been working. The inquiries place increasing strain on the already traumatized pilot. Driven to question himself by the allegations, Sullenburger begins to contemplate the capitulation of not only his newfound status but his career and personal life.
 
Despite the suggestion of its rather placid title, Sully is in fact a taut psychological drama. At its heart is the Capt. Sullenburger, broodingly played by Tom Hanks, providing one of his best performances since his last skipper-related role Captain Phillips. The aging pilot is racked with self-doubt. His actions are always minimal – he stares, pauses and frowns – but the small gestures neatly present a man overwhelmed by how far he feels he is plummeting. The film finds more dramatic fair in returning to the flight. Selectively edited versions of the plane’s spiraling descent are replayed as the protagonist relives his now tortured memory, trying to recall his actions at the height of panic. Each does just a little to suggest some guilt. Was he too quick to choose a river landing? Did his failing consultancy business in airplane safety create a conflict of interests? Only in the film’s final moments is the true path of events revealed.


Image credit: Warner Brothers

Doubts come from without as well as within. The slimy NTSB lawyers, led by the ruthlessly officious Charles Porter (Mike O’Malley), hound Sully into admitting the subjectivity of his actions. The tests have been run and the data gathered, they constantly reiterate, and the captain “objectively” chose wrongly. The arguments quickly evolve into the age-old contest of man versus machine. The human – Sully – acted on fallible impulse; computers do not. “Simulations” almost become a dirty word as it is endlessly spat across the meeting room table, supposedly proving the incontrovertible and indisputable that the pilot was at fault. This awesome technological opponent gradually overpowers the film’s protagonist – and the audience to some extent – forcing him to admit defeat. It may not look like Terminator, but Clint Eastwood’s picture flies in the same skies.
 
Herein, however, lies Sully’s largest faults. In pinning the antagonist role on computers, the film creates a straw-man villain. Is it possible that the simulations have been incorrectly calibrated? The film presents Capt. Sullenburger’s realization of this concept as a discovery akin to Gallileo’s eureka moment, but to most of the audience this will appear obvious. Stop for a moment and you realize the fault here is with boring old humans, slightly denting Sully’s anti-computer crusade. The shaky ideology is not helped by a (fittingly) sky-diving ex-machina relating to the discovery of an engine in the film’s final moments.
 
Above it all, Sully struggles with the weight of its “true story” status. We already know that Capt. Sullenburger was not disgraced, constantly undermining the film’s attempts to build an uncertain conclusion. That is not to say Clint Eastwood’s film is without merits: there are extended moments of tension and drama in the fraught boardroom scenes. Sully, however, always feels like its flying against the breeze. Its ideas never truly land safely to ground, leaving one strangely wishing for a slightly darker conclusion.
 
*** - 3/5 Stars
 
Sully opens in theatres on 2 December. The film is directed by Clint Eastwood, and stars Tom Hanks, Aaron Eckhart and Valerie Mahaffey. It is a certificate 12A.
 

Tell us what you think

You may also like

‘Being haunted by the past is something I’m creatively turned on by’ - An Interview with Brian J Smith

‘Being haunted by the past is something I’m creatively turned on by’ - An Interview with Brian J Smith

Science fiction fans may be particularly familiar with Texas born Brian J Smith. He got his big break playing Lieutenant Matthew Scott in military science…

Free Fire - An Interview with Ben Wheatley

Free Fire - An Interview with Ben Wheatley

Ben Wheatley’s films are sick and twisted in the best way possible. With Free Fire, the genre experimenter goes for pure fun, delivering a 70s-set action-comedy…

This Week 27 March - 2 April

This Week 27 March - 2 April

The days are getting longer and (very gradually) getting warmer, so it’s time to go outside! Follow along the path of nature to discover Moomins and…

The Best Places to Watch the Boat Race in London

The Best Places to Watch the Boat Race in London

The Boat Race – a contest between two of the Britain’s most elite and exclusive universities in a sport watched approximately twice a year that incomprehensibly…

Walk of Shame – An Interview with Eleanor Conway

Walk of Shame – An Interview with Eleanor Conway

Eleanor Conway began her career as a music journalist, travelling the world and interviewing some of the music industry’s biggest names. A ferocious clubber and party…

Brexit, moving to London and Denial - An Interview with Rachel Weisz

Brexit, moving to London and Denial - An Interview with Rachel Weisz

London born and Cambridge educated, Rachel Weisz has wowed audiences from her breakthrough role as Egyptologist Evelyn in The Mummy to her Oscar-winning performance as…

Amy Winehouse: A Family Portrait

Amy Winehouse: A Family Portrait

You might think you know Amy Winehouse. The caricatured, instantly recognisable figure in tiny 1950s style dotted dresses with a colossal beehive of black hair,…

Don’t Wake The Beast - An Interview with Kill The Beast

Don’t Wake The Beast - An Interview with Kill The Beast

“We’re all friends because we’re weirdos,” says Clem Garritty, one fifth of theatre company Kill The Beast. “We just hope other people like the stuff that makes us…

‘You don’t want to play the goofy sidekick or best friend characters anymore’ - An Interview with Dev Patel

‘You don’t want to play the goofy sidekick or best friend characters anymore’ - An Interview with Dev Patel

Born in West London, we first saw Dev Patel on our screens in the anarchic Bristol-based TV drama Skins, before he got the biggest of…

Australia’s Impressionists at The National Gallery

Australia’s Impressionists at The National Gallery

The Australian Impressionists of the late 19th Century attempted to depict a country undergoing huge changes, a nation searching for an identity, a land with…

More inspiration...

‘Being haunted by the past is something I’m creatively turned on by’ - An Interview with Brian J Smith

‘Being haunted by the past is something I’m creatively turned on by’ - An Interview with Brian J Smith

We spoke to Stargate Universe and Sense 8 actor about his latest role in the Glass Menagerie, the roles that most inspire him and the surprising purchase he made with his first acting paycheck.
Free Fire - An Interview with Ben Wheatley

Free Fire - An Interview with Ben Wheatley

Ben Wheatley’s films are sick and twisted in the best way possible. We talk to him about his latest film, Free Fire.
This Week 27 March - 2 April

This Week 27 March - 2 April

We find out what will be keeping you occupied in the capital this week.
The Best Places to Watch the Boat Race in London

The Best Places to Watch the Boat Race in London

Whether you're Oxford, Cambridge or (literally) somewhere in between, find out the best places to watch the Boat Race 2017.
Deutsche Börse Prize Exhibition at the Photographers’ Gallery

Deutsche Börse Prize Exhibition at the Photographers’ Gallery

This diverse exhibition takes in landscapes, travel diaries and post-modern self-portraits.

Your inbox deserves a little culture!